Re: [idn] Chinese Domain Name Consortium (CDNC) Declaration

["xiang deng" <deng@cnnic.net.cn>]

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Paul Hoffman / IMC" <phoffman@imc.org>

> The message from CDNC says that the Traditional-Simplified problem 
> for Chinese users cannot be solved by registration policy. This is 
> not true, and many of the CDNC members who have come to IETF meetings 
> know that. Of course, CDNC members would like to maximize their 
> financial gain in registration, but the concern of the IETF is always 
> towards helping users. There is a huge different between "cannot be 
> solved" and "it will cost a small number of organizations a lot of 
> money".

If you want talk about financial problem, let me correct it:
TC/SC solution(or registration solution ) will save user's money and cost registrar's money
DON'T do TC/SC will cost user's money and make money for registrar.
So what your comment is distorting fact.

And, Please give me a successiveful example of such registration solution.

> Due to the efforts of some CDNC members, the IETF is now well aware 
> of the "2^n" variant problem that is unique to the use of Han 
> characters in the Chinese language. Fortunately, using registration 
> guidelines will solve the problem. 

Who will follow this registration guideline? All administrators?

Regards. 
Deng xiang