[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: draft-despres-v6ops-6rd-ipv6-rapid-deployment
On Tue, 11 Mar 2008, james woodyatt wrote:
It seems to me that 2002::/16, the 6to4 prefix, can be regarded as a special
case of 6rd ISP prefix allocated by IANA and unassigned to any particular
organization. What 6RD does is allow each ISP to define their own 6to4-like
routing domain, provided that CPE functions are properly loaded with the 6rd
ISP prefix to use as distinguished from the 2002::/16 prefix assigned by
IANA.
The draft defines a new DHCPv4 option used by 6RD ISP to configure
6RD-enabled CPE, i.e. hosts or dual-stack IPv4/IPv6 routers with
6RD-tunneling functions. I very much doubt that getting vendors of consumer
retail CPE, e.g. host operating systems, consumer routers, etc., to adopt
this DHCP client feature will be easy. For that reason, I don't expect 6RD
to be deployable except with provider-provisioned CPE.
Agreed about deployment caveats and that part of 6rd being a trivial
extension of 6to4 concept. That'll no longer be the case if you don't
embed the complete v4 address in IPv6 prefix.
I'd be opposed to specifying a mechanism which would require an ISP to
use a whole /32 prefix for this because that would screw up existing
allocations and would deter ISPs from applying this mechanism.
One major point to consider in this context is whether you want the
hosts/routers to be able to communicate directly with each other (in
which case they also need to know how to calculate the IPv4 address if
the full IPv4 address is not provided in the IPv6 prefix) or whether
it's sufficient to just tunnel everything to the ISP's IPv6
aggregation boxes.
The former is more difficult to generalize but provides better p2p
traffic optimization.
The latter approach and specifically how you could do a partial map
map from subset of v4 to v6 was described in 2003-2004 around Section
5.3 of: http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-savola-v6ops-conftun-setup-02
This also supports multicast without a problem.
--
Pekka Savola "You each name yourselves king, yet the
Netcore Oy kingdom bleeds."
Systems. Networks. Security. -- George R.R. Martin: A Clash of Kings