Re: [idn] Re: DNSSEC compatibility

[James Seng <James@Seng.cc>]

Edmon wrote:
> There shouldnt be any reason why IDNs could not be integrated with DNSSEC...

There is no reason why IDNs must use DNS protocol either.

So long it serve the purpose of Internationalized Domain Names, meeting
the requirements I-D, we can and will consider it.

Nothing is out of question here.

-James Seng

> > DNSSEC is more complicated than necessary due to the need to
> > accomodate existing DNS RRs with no modification to their format.
> > if we had the necessity of writing a different protocol for IDNs,
> > the equivalent of DNSSEC would be a lot simpler.
> >
> > IMHO, The requirement should be that IDNs have authentication and
> > integrity assurance which is at least as good as DNSSEC.
> >
> > Keit