[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Confirmation of HTTPS use for the port 832
Dear all,
At the Montreal meeting, IANA-assigned ports are reported as following.
netconf-ssh 830/tcp NETCONF over SSH
netconf-beep 831/tcp NETCONF over BEEP
netconfsoaphttp 832/tcp NETCONF for SOAP over HTTP
netconfsoapbeep 833/tcp NETCONF for SOAP over BEEP
I would like to confirm the following points.
- We use HTTPS rather than HTTP as the transport of NETCONF/SOAP/HTTP.
(In ML, the word "SOAP/HTTPS" is always used.)
- We use same port 832 for HTTP, when there is some reason to use HTTP.
I concern that proto-12 and soap-08 draft are ambiguous about these points.
It seems that there is no sentence definitely specifying the use of HTTPS.
# Section 2.4 of soap-08 says "Use HTTPS" only.
To clarify the use of HTTPS, I suggest
1. to ask IANA to change the description of assigned port
of NETCONF/SOAP/HTTP as following, if possible.
netconfsoaphttps 832/tcp NETCONF for SOAP over HTTPS
netconfsoaphttps 832/udp NETCONF for SOAP over HTTPS
2. to add the following sentence in the last of section 2.4 "BCP56:..."
of soap-08 draft to avoid the anbiguity.
"As these reasons, NETCONF system SHOULD use HTTPS
when it use SOAP and HTTP as the transport."
And, how about the following sentence in the last of section 4?
"If there is some reason to use HTTP rather than HTTPS,
the opeartor configures the NETCONF manager and devices
to use HTTP on the IANA-assined port (832) for theier session"
Regards,
Hideki Okita
hideki.okita.pf@hitachi.com
Central Research Laboratory, Hitachi Ltd.
--
to unsubscribe send a message to netconf-request@ops.ietf.org with
the word 'unsubscribe' in a single line as the message text body.
archive: <http://ops.ietf.org/lists/netconf/>