[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[idn] stringprep comment 2



 
In stringprep  section 6,
 
" 6. Unassigned Code Points in Stringprep Profiles

This section describes two different types of strings in typical
protocols where internationalized strings are used: "stored strings" and
"queries". Of course, different Internet protocols use strings very
differently, so these terms cannot be used exactly in every protocol
that needs to use stringprep. In general, "stored strings" are strings
that are used in protocol identifiers and named entities, such as names
in digital certificates, DNS domain name parts, and names of SNMP objects.
"Queries" are strings that are used to match against strings that are
stored identifiers, such as user-entered names for digital certificate
authorities, DNS lookups, and SNMP requests. "
 
 
Is this classification from  over-simplifications ? only two types?  
Is there any 3rd type possible?
 
To be complete, 'typical' ,'cannot .. exactly' and 'in general' had better be removed and
the classification should  first define "strored strings" precisely and  then
define the complement set  as the "queries"  if it is proved that any 3rd type does not exist.
 
I have doubt that there are many *gray areas* that  do not fall into either categories.
 
Soobok Lee