Fwd: Re: CDI status

["Phil Rzewski" <philr@inktomi.com>]

FYI, looks like we're almost there. I updated the charter with their
recommendations and will let you know when we have the green light. There
may be champagne in Minneapolis. :)

--
Phil


>Date: Thu, 10 Jan 2002 09:07:13 -0800
>From: Patrik Fältström <paf@cisco.com>
>To: Phil Rzewski <philr@inktomi.com>
>cc: Ned Freed <ned.freed@mrochek.com>
>Subject: Re: CDI status
>X-Mailer: Mulberry/2.1.2 (Mac OS X)
>
>--On 2002-01-10 08.26 -0800 Phil Rzewski <philr@inktomi.com> wrote:
>
>> Hi Patrik. I recall today was the day that you said the IESG may approve
>> CDI's status as a WG. Can you give me an update on that?
>
>We have just discussed it. Things are ok part from details in the text
>below. With some small changes, the group is created.
>
>Comments:
>
>(1)
>
>> A thing that concerns me about the CDI milestones, besides
>> the notes below, is the May 1 one not saying which documents.
>> The group may get expansive ideas about further documents
>> that are "non-requirements" but needed, though I think they've
>> done a good job at separating away discussions of protocols.
>
>I.e. you have to list more explicitly what documents.
>
>(2)
>
>> Also, there are requirements tucked into the framework and
>> model at least.  Suggestion, one milestone for each of the seven
>> deliverables.
>
>(3)
>
>> "streaming or continuous media delivered via RTSP" - RTSP sets up
>> and controls delivery, but the delivery is done by other protocols.
>> Suggested change:  "streaming or continuous media which are controlled
>> by RTSP."
>
>(4)
>> March 17-22, 2002: Meet at IETF53 to resolve issues 
>
>Should not be a milestone.
>
>(5)
>> May 1, 2002: All supporting (non-requirements) documents published as
>> RFCs  by this date. 
>
>Only thing you can say is that the documents are forwarded to the IESG for
>publication as RFC's. Not that they are published.
>
>(6)
>> June 1, 2002: Request-routing requirements and distribution
>> requirements  published as RFCs by this date. 
>
>See (5).
>
>     paf
> 
--
Phil Rzewski - Senior Architect - Inktomi Corporation                  
650-653-2487 (office) - 650-303-3790 (cell) - 650-653-1848 (fax)