Re: [idn] Re: IDN requirements doc

[James Seng <James@Seng.cc>]

Miss this out :-)

> Karlsson Kent - keka wrote:
> Aha.  But then please rephrase (avoiding the word 'illegal'):
> 
> IDN MUST NOT return non-IDN characters (to be defined) in
> responses, and SHOULD reject queries containing non-IDN characters.

Hence, I recommend that [12.5] be remove and in place,

The protocol MUST NOT reject any non-IDN characters (to be defined) in any
queries or response.

> I still see a problem with this, in that the UCS is open, and
> new characters will be added to it for quite some time.

Which is the reason the protocol must not prevent any codepoint.

-James Seng