[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: TE Measurement - v03 comments
Thanks for your comments, Merike.
This is very helpful.
Dr. Richard W. Tibbs
Merike Kaeo wrote:
Here are the comments I had and promised to forward to this group
regarding the TE Measurements document:
- there are many sections where I felt there should be clarification
on whether active or passive measurements were being discussed....and
if both, then point out any different considerations for each (or
state there should be same consideration). I have notes on this for
sections 7 (Read Out Periods), 8 (Measurement Basis), 8.2 and 8.3
- the document makes references to both IPPM and ITU documents and
sometimes notes that there are differences (like long-term averages
for packet loss). It would be useful to know where the differences apply
- overall I felt the document had much useful information but it
needed applicability......draw some concrete conclusions. It is
written in the intro that "A major goal is to provide guidance for
establishing protocol-independent and platform-neutral traffic
measurement standards to achieve multi-vendor inter- operability". I
thought that most of the information was there but I wasn't clear at
the end of the document what to do with all the measurement parameters
listed and felt there was still much room for ambiguous measurements.
- merike