[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
RE: LMP MIB
I guess I don't understand the process of WGs.
And I think I should udnerstand it as an AD should I not?
But if I were a document author/editor, or if I were a WG
co-chair, then, before I would even consider a MIB document
to be ready for WG last call, then I would make SURE that
the MIB in that document compiles clean.
I fed the MIB to SMICng. It causes lots of trouble, errors,
warnings. It also depends on the mpls bundle mib. Which in
turn also cause lots of trouble and warnings. 21 Errors
and 51 warnings all together.
Below is the report. PLEASE PLEASE fix those things FIRST.
And I did not look at the content at all yet.
Bert
--------- SMICng report ----------
In file mplsbundle.mi2
80: REVISION
81: "200105223200Z" -- 22 May 2001 12:00:00 EST
^
W: REVISION value "200105223200Z" is not a valid extended UTC time
1124:
1125: OBJECT teLinkRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkRowStatus"
1132:
1133: OBJECT teLinkStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkStorageType"
1140:
1141: OBJECT teLinkDescrRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkDescrRowStatus"
1147:
1148: OBJECT teLinkDescrStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkDescrStorageType"
1156: OBJECT teLinkOspfLinkId
1157: SYNTAX INTEGER { pointToPoint(1) }
^
E: Syntax type does not match that for "teLinkOspfLinkId"
1155:
1156: OBJECT teLinkOspfLinkId
^
E: MIN-ACCESS value incompatible with access specified for "teLinkOspfLinkId"
1163:
1164: OBJECT srlgRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "srlgRowStatus"
1171:
1172: OBJECT srlgStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "srlgStorageType"
1179:
1180: OBJECT teLinkBandwidthRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkBandwidthRowStatus"
1187:
1188: OBJECT teLinkBandwidthStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkBandwidthStorageType"
1195:
1196: OBJECT dataBearingChannelRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "dataBearingChannelRowStatus"
1203:
1204: OBJECT dataBearingChannelStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "dataBearingChannelStorageType"
1211:
1212: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "dataBearingChannelDescrRowStatus"
1218:
1219: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "dataBearingChannelDescrStorageType"
1226:
1227: OBJECT dataBearingChannelBwRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "dataBearingChannelBwRowStatus"
1234:
1235: OBJECT dataBearingChannelBwStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "dataBearingChannelBwStorageType"
1211:
1212: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrRowStatus
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelDescrRowStatus" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1218:
1219: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrStorageType
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelDescrStorageType" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1226:
1227: OBJECT dataBearingChannelBwRowStatus
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelBwRowStatus" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1234:
1235: OBJECT dataBearingChannelBwStorageType
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelBwStorageType" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1314: OBJECT teLinkOspfLinkId
1315: SYNTAX INTEGER { pointToPoint(1) }
^
E: Syntax type does not match that for "teLinkOspfLinkId"
1313:
1314: OBJECT teLinkOspfLinkId
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "teLinkOspfLinkId"
1375:
1376: OBJECT dataBearingChannelEncodingType
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelEncodingType" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1380:
1381: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrPriority
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelDescrPriority" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1385:
1386: OBJECT dataBearingChannelMinReservableBandwidth
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelMinReservableBandwidth" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1390:
1391: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrRowStatus
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelDescrRowStatus" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1397:
1398: OBJECT dataBearingChannelDescrStorageType
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelDescrStorageType" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1405:
1406: OBJECT dataBearingChannelBwRowStatus
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelBwRowStatus" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
1413:
1414: OBJECT dataBearingChannelBwStorageType
^
E: OBJECT-TYPE "dataBearingChannelBwStorageType" is not in a MANDATORY or conditional group for module "LINK-BUNDLING-MIB"
4: MODULE-IDENTITY, OBJECT-TYPE, NOTIFICATION-TYPE,
5: experimental, Integer32, Unsigned32
^
W: "Integer32" imported but not used
10:
11: TEXTUAL-CONVENTION, TruthValue, RowStatus, StorageType,
^
W: "TEXTUAL-CONVENTION" imported but not used
11: TEXTUAL-CONVENTION, TruthValue, RowStatus, StorageType,
12: RowPointer, TimeStamp
^
W: "RowPointer" imported but not used
^
W: "TimeStamp" imported but not used
14:
15: InterfaceIndex, InterfaceIndexOrZero, ifIndex
^
W: "InterfaceIndex" imported but not used
21:
22: InetAddressType, InetAddress
^
W: "InetAddressType" imported but not used
------------------------------------------------------------------
In file lmp.mi2
134: "This value represents a Node ID."
135: SYNTAX InetAddress
^
E: In defining TC "NodeID", cannot define using syntax "InetAddress", which is another TC
1448: -- SONET/SDH encoding type:
1449: j016OverheadBytes(1),
^
E: First named bit for BITS must be position zero
194: every pair of nodes that can establish control channels."
195: INDEX { lmpNbrNodeId }
^
E: Index item "lmpNbrNodeId" may not have "read-write", "write-only", "read-create", or "accessible-for-notify" access
207:
208: lmpNbrNodeId OBJECT-TYPE
^
E: Item "lmpNbrNodeId" has invalid value for MAX-ACCESS because it is an index column
386: well (see RFC 2863)."
387: INDEX { lmpCcId }
^
E: Index item "lmpCcId" may not have "read-write", "write-only", "read-create", or "accessible-for-notify" access
414:
415: lmpCcId OBJECT-TYPE
^
E: Item "lmpCcId" has invalid value for MAX-ACCESS because it is an index column
1878: lmpDataBearingLinkPropertyMismatch NOTIFICATION-TYPE
1879: OBJECTS { ifStackHigherLayer,
^
E: Variable "ifStackHigherLayer" in notification "lmpDataBearingLinkPropertyMismatch" has access of "not-accessible"
2517: lmpCcBeginVerifySent,
2518: lmpCcBeginVerifyReceived,
^
W: Duplicate item "lmpCcBeginVerifyReceived" in object-group "lmpPerfGroup" OBJECTS list
2524: lmpCcEndVerifySent,
2525: lmpCcEndVerifyReceived,
^
W: Duplicate item "lmpCcEndVerifyReceived" in object-group "lmpPerfGroup" OBJECTS list
2529: lmpCcTestStatusSuccessSent,
2530: lmpCcTestStatusSuccessReceived,
^
W: Duplicate item "lmpCcTestStatusSuccessReceived" in object-group "lmpPerfGroup" OBJECTS list
2532: lmpCcTestStatusFailureSent,
2533: lmpCcTestStatusFailureReceived,
^
W: Duplicate item "lmpCcTestStatusFailureReceived" in object-group "lmpPerfGroup" OBJECTS list
908:
909: lmpCcBeginVerifyRetransmit OBJECT-TYPE
^
W: Item "lmpCcBeginVerifyRetransmit" is not contained in any group defined in the current module
972:
973: lmpCcEndVerifyRetransmit OBJECT-TYPE
^
W: Item "lmpCcEndVerifyRetransmit" is not contained in any group defined in the current module
1018:
1019: lmpCcTestStatusSuccessRetransmit OBJECT-TYPE
^
W: Item "lmpCcTestStatusSuccessRetransmit" is not contained in any group defined in the current module
1045:
1046: lmpCcTestStatusFailureRetransmit OBJECT-TYPE
^
W: Item "lmpCcTestStatusFailureRetransmit" is not contained in any group defined in the current module
1054:
1055: lmpCcTestStatusAckReceived OBJECT-TYPE
^
W: Item "lmpCcTestStatusAckReceived" is not contained in any group defined in the current module
1063:
1064: lmpCcTestStatusAckSent OBJECT-TYPE
^
W: Item "lmpCcTestStatusAckSent" is not contained in any group defined in the current module
1992:
1993: OBJECT lmpNbrRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpNbrRowStatus"
2000:
2001: OBJECT lmpNbrStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpNbrStorageType"
2008:
2009: OBJECT lmpCcRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpCcRowStatus"
2016:
2017: OBJECT lmpCcOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpCcOperStatus"
2023:
2024: OBJECT lmpCcStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpCcStorageType"
2031:
2032: OBJECT lmpTeLinkOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpTeLinkOperStatus"
2037:
2038: OBJECT lmpTeLinkRowStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpTeLinkRowStatus"
2045:
2046: OBJECT lmpTeLinkStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpTeLinkStorageType"
2053:
2054: OBJECT lmpDataBearingLinkActiveOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpDataBearingLinkActiveOperStatus"
2059:
2060: OBJECT lmpDataBearingLinkPassiveOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpDataBearingLinkPassiveOperStatus"
2074:
2075: OBJECT lmpDataBearingLinkStorageType
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpDataBearingLinkStorageType"
2254:
2255: OBJECT lmpCcOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpCcOperStatus"
2307:
2308: OBJECT lmpTeLinkOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpTeLinkOperStatus"
2366:
2367: OBJECT lmpDataBearingLinkActiveOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpDataBearingLinkActiveOperStatus"
2372:
2373: OBJECT lmpDataBearingLinkPassiveOperStatus
^
W: MIN-ACCESS value identical to access specified for "lmpDataBearingLinkPassiveOperStatus"
4: MODULE-IDENTITY, OBJECT-TYPE, NOTIFICATION-TYPE,
5: experimental, Integer32, Unsigned32, Counter32, TimeTicks
^
W: "Integer32" imported but not used
11: TEXTUAL-CONVENTION, TruthValue, RowStatus, StorageType,
12: RowPointer, TimeStamp
^
W: "RowPointer" imported but not used
14:
15: InterfaceIndex, InterfaceIndexOrZero, ifIndex, ifStackHigherLayer
^
W: "InterfaceIndex" imported but not used
17:
18: InetAddressType, InetAddress
^
W: "InetAddressType" imported but not used
*** 21 errors and 51 warnings in parsing
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Kireeti Kompella [mailto:kireeti@juniper.net]
> Sent: Thursday, April 11, 2002 7:34 PM
> To: ccamp@ops.ietf.org
> Subject: LMP MIB
>
>
> The authors of the LMP MIB
> draft-ietf-ccamp-lmp-mib-01.txt
> feel that it is ready for WG Last Call.
>
> Please comment by COB April 18th, especially if you think this
> work is *not* ready.
>
> Authors: please read the ID Nits page and make any editorial
> corrections needed, preferably prior to WG Last Call.
>
> Kireeti.
>
>
- Follow-Ups:
- RE: LMP MIB
- From: "Thomas D. Nadeau" <tnadeau@cisco.com>