What exactly do we want to be in this RFC?
think it needs to build on the observation that there is no congruenceI disagree. The whole point of this RFC would be to end the discussion. That's not going to happen by simply presenting one viewpoint. Either it needs to be an overview that lists all the arguments pro and con and possibly drawing some conclusions along the way, or if it only presents a single point of view it must get into the nitty gritty and not suffice with "I know someone in Jakarta who connects to Reykjavik so geo aggregation can't work".
between network topology and geography to show that we have no way to make
geo addresses aggregate in practice. It doesn't need to be that long.
But since it's an abstract "why this doesn't work" argument, I think
it needs to be separate from any specific technical proposal.