[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
MIB review guidelines open issues list
I've attached a list of open issues for
I think it covers everything that's been
discussed on the mreview list so far. Please
let me know if I missed anything.
It would be nice if we could get the bulk of
these resolved in time to post an updated
draft well before the IETF-56 blackout date
of March 3rd.
Issue Section Status Comments
More specific security 3.6 Open Text proposed by Bert & Mike;
instructions are needed additions requested by dbh.
Importing items used in 4.4 Open Text proposed to change from
compliance statements & MAY to RECOMMENDED; call for
capabilities statements consensus issued.
Gauge32 as an index 188.8.131.52 Ready s/appropriate/acceptable/ in
paragraph on Gauge32 as index
Counter Discontinuity 184.108.40.206 Open Adding ifCounterDiscontinuityTime
Indicators as an example is proposed;
One houe rule 220.127.116.11 Open Editor has proposed text to
rescind the one-hour rule as
obsolete; awaiting feedback.
Non-contiguous BITS 18.104.22.168 Open Current text says they are not
enumerations allowed; RFC 2578 allows them
only in revisions; awaiting
feedback on whether any form
of ban is a CLR that should be
done away with.
Should it be explicitly 4.6.4 Open Editor has agreed to add such
statted that objects text if there is feedback
SHOULD NOT be registered requesting it.
beneath groups, MCs, ACs
Should it be mandated 4.6.5 Open This was suggested on the list
that overall index size when we discussed the APM-MIB;
limit be spelled out in awaiting feedback.
tables where SIZE clauses
do not enforce the 128
Should guidelines say 4.6.x Open Editor has requested that the
something about not proponents explain why IMPLIED
unsing IMPLIED is a bad idea.
Should index objects 4.7 Open This was not mentioned because
in notifications be most index objects these days
NOT RECOMMENDED are inaccessible, and so are
not eligible in the first place.
Editor will add such text if it
is requested; awaiting feedback.
Typos in 4.9 para 4 4.9 Ready s/implemantations/implementations/
Does SMICng include Appendix C Open The include file in Appendix C
file need to be updated was built for book version 2.2.07